Dubai’s business environment has changed dramatically after the imposition of VAT in 2018 and the introduction of Corporate Tax in 2023. The compliance rules for business operators in this emirate are more stringent than before. Many people still struggle to understand the fundamental question: when does my company need internal or external audit services?
This misunderstanding is a loss of regulatory goodwill, money, and time for businesses. The truth is simple: each audit serves a specific role in your compliance strategy. Because of these differences, you can work together with audit firms in Dubai more effectively, and your business will be safer from penalty fees and operating gaps.
What is Internal Audit?
Internal auditing is an impartial, objective assurance and consulting activity within an organization that seeks to enhance operations. It focuses on evaluating a company’s
- Internal controls.
- Governance
- Risk management procedures
An internal auditor is a firm employee or member of a designated internal team who regularly monitors business procedures, identifies inefficiencies and potential risks, and makes sure internal policies and regulations are followed.
Since internal auditsare ongoing, they give management feedback on how the business’s operations relate to its strategic goals. This feedback can help the business make process improvements. These audits have a flexible scope and can include financial controls, operational procedures, policy compliance, and cybersecurity measures.
What is an external audit?
The external audit is carried out by a third-party, independent audit firm that examines the company’s financial statements and renders an opinion on whether the statements are fair and comply with accounting standards such as GAAP (Generally Accepted Accounting Principles) or IFRS.
Most public firms have external audits performed by legal or regulatory bodies to validate that the financial information provided or displayed to stakeholders, investors, and the public is truthful and justified. The audits are performed once a year and mainly deal with the business’s financial integrity, verifying that there is no major truth-telling or fraud-related activity in the reported data. The corporation does not employ external auditors. It shows their objectivity and the dependability of their valuation.
Internal vs. External Audits
Audit Territories
Internal auditing focuses on various internal processes, divisions, and roles inside the organization. It is used to assess the efficacy of operations, compliance, and risk management throughout the entire organization.
Whereas, the organization’s financial health and the accuracy of financial statements are the main concerns of external audit. It evaluates whether the financial records are free of material errors.
Accountability Frameworks
Internal audit reports provide management and the board of directors with information on internal governance and improvement. The goal of this accountability framework is to support organizational goals.
External audit reports to external stakeholders, shareholders, regulators, and the public, and it is compliant and accountable to these external parties.
Time Considerations
Internal audits are performed on a continuous or scheduled basis throughout the year, depending on the needs of the business. It may be more flexible in terms of timing.
External audits are normally undertaken once a year, at the conclusion of the fiscal year, to review the organization’s comprehensive financial accounts.
Methodologies and Standards
Internal audits follow internal standards and risk management frameworks, which can differ significantly depending on the organization’s business goals and objectives.
External auditing, on the other hand, follows established accounting standards (such as GAAP or IFRS) as well as auditing standards issued by specialized authorities. It ensures reliability and consistency.
Oversight and autonomy
Internal auditing is overseen by management, who manage audit priorities and focus, which can lead to conflicts of interest.
External auditors act independently and with fairness, unbiasedness, and integrity, free of management interference, to objectively and fairly analyze the organization’s financial accounts.
Costs and Resources
Internal audits are typically less expensive when performed by internal staff. The size and complexity of an organization can have a significant impact on resource allocation.
External audit expenses are greater since they are often paid through external audit firms, which include the services and resources needed to comply with requirements.
Final Thoughts: How to select what’s best for your Business?
Finally, for most UAE organizations, the decision is not whether to opt for internal or external audits, but how to combine the two.
It’s advisable to opt for the obligatory external audit if you are a startup or small and medium-sized business to guarantee legal compliance, especially if you operate in a free zone with strict renewal requirements. Consider implementing internal audits as your company expands to improve productivity and risk control.
The best course of action is to combine the two if your company is large or expanding. While external audits verify your financial statements for stakeholders and regulators, internal audits are used to encourage strategic changes and manage internal risks.
No matter how big or small, it’s crucial to start by knowing what your particular free zone authority (if any) and the UAE Commercial Companies Law require. Consulting with a professional audit firm in the UAE can help you explain your mandatory requirements and develop an audit strategy that aligns with your business goals.